J.R.R. Tolkien’s Writing Process Teaches You How to Create Work That Matters – Special Reblog from Melissa Chu


This post was originally published on JumpStartYourDreamLife.com by author Melissa Chu. Sci Fi-Fantasy blog is pleased to be able to repost her excellent content.

Have you ever wondered how J.R.R. Tolkien wrote “The Lord of the Rings”? How he went about creating a world, various cultures, and a body of work that we continue to enjoy reading today?

If so, read on to see how he did it and what you can learn from his process.

On a dreary afternoon, a professor sat at his desk marking examination papers. He noticed that a student had left a page blank. Without any explanation, he found himself jotting down the sentence: “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.”

This line sparked J.R.R. Tolkien’s idea for The Hobbit, which was published in 1937. It was an immediate success. Stanley Unwin, the Chairman of the publishing firm, asked him if he had any other similar stories available to meet public demand.

In response, Tolkien wrote a full book of tales and named it The Silmarillion. Some of the tales were sent off to Unwin, who decided that they weren’t commercially publishable. Instead, he asked Tolkien if he could write a sequel to The Hobbit.

Disappointed, Tolkien agreed to Unwin’s request and went back to work. The publishing firm did not expect a profit and decided they would incur a probable loss of 1,000 pounds. But, when they published the story during 1954 and 1955, what came next surprised them.

The trilogy immediately captured the public’s attention. It was adapted to radio the following year, and it has since gone on to sell over 150 million copies [1]. Later, The Lord of the Rings was turned into one of the highest-grossing and most critically-acclaimed film series of all time. The trilogy is considered one of the greatest book series of the twentieth century.

The Complex Process of Creating a World

It took J.R.R. Tolkien over a dozen years to plan and write “The Lord of the Rings.”

If you’ve read the trilogy, you can see the level of detail he put into creating the world of Middle-earth. The world contains many different peoples, languages, regions, geographies, and histories, amongst other elements.

So, how exactly did he manage to complete such a gargantuan task – and weave engaging storylines into the invented world on top of it all?

In his words, he “wisely started with a map, and made the story fit” [2]. To create the map of Middle-earth, he sketched small pieces here and there. Some were hasty outlines scribbled onto the corner of a page, while others were painstakingly drawn in detail.

Tolkien revised his maps repeatedly. Over the course of multiple sketches, Saruman’s tower changed from round and tiered to a more severe structure. This change is reflected in The Two Towers, where his final description of Orthanc reads: “A peak and isle of rock it was, black and gleaming hard: four mighty piers of many-sided stone were welded into one.”

While the maps were the foundation of the story, the plot later shaped what the map looked like as well. For one thing, Tolkien took care to ensure that Frodo and Sam’s traveling speed and location matched the map dimensions. He also accounted for mountain slopes and steepness.

Why? It was important that the two arrived at Mount Doom at the same time that Aragorn led his army to battle at the Black Gate. To fit his evolving storylines, Tolkien placed new maps over old ones throughout the course of his writing.

Tolkien’s Strategies for Creating Good Work

What I found most interesting about Tolkien’s process was that he didn’t simply sit down and write. Before he began writing the first novel, he planned, drew, and revised the world of Middle-earth.

What can his approach show us about creating good work? Three things:

1. Lay the groundwork.

Tolkien’s writing wasn’t just based on words. It was the result of imagery that he pictured, sketched, and perfected. To describe objects and places, he first had to visualize them on paper.

Before you start on a project, you need to set the foundation. Understand the basics first. For instance, if you’re a beginner in tennis, you don’t start by competing against an opponent. You have to understand the rules of the court, the game set-up, and the right posture. There’s a lot of preparation that comes before you hit your first ball.

2. Perform little failures.

Tolkien looked at his drafts with a critical eye, calling them “amateur”. He frequently changed the names of places and peoples, and he changed the routes his characters took. He sketched out places knowing full well that they would be revised repeatedly until they suited his liking.

Testing out concepts helps us create something concrete that we can use and build upon. Failure isn’t always bad – we can use it as feedback for the future. We can figure out whether our design makes sense and how to improve it. When developing a business idea, entrepreneurs use the same process of testing the validity of an idea on a small scale.

3. Let the work reveal itself.

It’s hard to believe that one individual created a volume of work like “The Lord of the Rings”. At one point, Tolkien offered the trilogy to a rival publisher, which backed away when the editors saw the scale of his creation.

As for his writing process, Tolkien didn’t see himself as creating a story from scratch. Instead, he let the story gradually unfold on its own: “I have long ceased to invent… I wait till I seem to know what really happened. Or till it writes itself.”

Sometimes the work you create takes on a life of its own, and that’s a good thing. We can only plan up to a certain point. Situations change and new ideas sprout up along the way. You may end up going down a path that you hadn’t expected before.

Start with the Foundation

Tolkien must have had a lot of patience to spend over a decade building a world and creating a story within it. Even though his story grew longer and more complex than expected, he managed to put everything together into a finished product.

In life, many of us want to go right to the end result without doing the important work first. For instance, we want to:

Earn money without figuring out how to provide value.
Perform at a concert without practicing our music.
Become fit without evaluating environmental factors we’re exposing ourselves to (i.e. what type of food and snacks we surround ourselves with).
It’s easy to get overwhelmed and drained when we think about all the steps we have to take to get to a destination. These feelings can make it hard to make any sort of progress. We focus so deeply on the end result that we forget where to start.

You don’t know exactly where your journey will lead you. Instead of fixating on every single detail, work on the things that are within your reach.

Lay the groundwork first.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s